Is 5 Inch Deep Enough For A Flower Garden

The ideal height for a raised bed is a matter of preference for gardeners. Considerations include the cost of raised beds, the condition of the soil beneath the bed, soil depth requirements for the intended crop, and especially important to mature gardeners, how much bending over you want to do.

Container gardening also requires gardeners to understand the rooting requirements of different crops. Since gardening containers and planters have bottoms, the soil depth is limited.

These considerations are discussed in the guide below, with charts showing the rooting depths needed for different vegetables and the sizes of plants at maturity.

Preparing the Ground for Raised Garden Beds

'Double Dig' the Ground Beneath Your Raised Beds

Raised garden beds (see options available in store) are open on the bottom which enables plant roots to access soil nutrients below ground level. When first setting up a raised bed, gardeners should 'double-dig' the soil beneath the raised bed. This only needs to be done once and is much easier if done before the raised bed is assembled in place.

Double-digging refers to two shovel blade lengths, or approximately 24" in depth. This is done to remove rocks and any debris, which would obstruct root growth; it also gives the gardener a chance to see if there are any other roots encroaching into the soil space. Nearby trees, for example, may be sending roots as far as 50' laterally underground in search of available nutrients. (see our article How to Block Tree Roots from Entering Your Garden) Double-digging provides a reservoir of nutrients and water for your plants' deeper roots.

Double-digging also lets the gardener see the condition of underlying soil so it can be determined which soil amendments to add. For example, if the soil appears clay-like, then it will need to be lightened with peat to provide aeration and improve drainage.

Add Amendments to Improve the Subsoil

Once you have prepared your plot and cleared away rocks, add peat moss as needed to lighten the soil. Since peat is acidic, add lime to balance the soil pH. Rock phosphate can also be sprinkled in at this time. Now the raised bed can be assembled and topped up with soil. Once the bed is filled to within a few inches of the top, add fertilizer and compost. These final amendments should be added within a week or two of planting, since you don't want early spring rains to wash these valuable amendments too deeply into the soil.

To learn more about building rich soil, see 6 Tips for Building Soil in Raised Garden Beds and Planters.

preparing the soil in raised garden beds
The soil in these raised beds is being prepared for planting. Compost and fertilizer will be added to top up the beds.

If you look carefully, you can see the aluminum cross-braces on the lower bed. These will be covered with more soil.

Note the beds are built with a taper to the sides. This is because the garden is on sloping ground. For more information, read our article How to build raised beds on sloping ground.

How Tall Should a Raised Bed Be?

Consider Drainage

Besides the aesthetic appeal of raised beds and container gardens, they also provide good drainage for the soil within the bed. The most popular height for raised beds is 11″. (This is the height of two standard "2 x 6″ boards, which actually measure 1.5″ x 5.5".) This height provides sufficient drainage for most crops. For best results, there should be another 12″ or more of good soil below the bed. This gives your plants at least 18 – 20″ of soil. (The soil in raised beds is usually a few inches below the rim of the bed. This is because soil compresses after several waterings. Having the soil level down a few inches is useful because you will likely want to add a few inches of mulch.)

Raised beds drain readily and warm up earlier in spring. This means you can set out transplants sooner and extend your growing season.

Since raised beds are well drained and the soil is above ground level, the soil within the bed warms up earlier in the spring. This enables gardeners to set out transplants sooner which helps extend the growing season. A cold frame can be set on top of the bed during early spring to protect young seedlings and transplants from late frosts and strong winds. The cold frame can be lifted off the bed once the crops become established, and moved to another bed to help protect successive plantings.

How Much Bending Over Do You Want to Do?

If you are young, fit, and full of energy, then bending over or kneeling down to tend your garden may not be an issue. But if you are prone to back strain, or if you have any mobility issues, then a taller raised bed will make gardening easier.

In our garden, since the ground is sloped, the beds vary in height from 8″ – 24″. Since we are 'mature' gardeners, we really notice the difference in working the various beds. The 24″ beds are much easier on the back when tilling the soil, setting in transplants, weeding and thinning, adding mulch, and harvesting.

Container gardening in elevated planters is another option for gardeners with limited mobility. These gardens can be tended while sitting in a wheelchair. However, the same principles apply in container gardens with respect to soil depth requirements, top-dressing amendments such as compost, fertilizer, and mulch. And taller plants grown in container gardens usually require staking or tying to trellis. For more information, read our article about Wheelchair Gardening Tips.

Taller Beds May Need Cross-Supports

The taller you build your raised bed, the more volume it will hold. As the soil is watered it becomes heavier and this exerts pressure, which may cause your bed to bow outward in mid-span, near the top. If the bed is taller than 12″ and longer than 6′, it will likely require a cross-support in the center of the span, across the width of the bed, to keep the sides from bowing.

Manufacturers of raised beds often supply these supports, but if you are building your own beds, then you may want to include this feature. The cross-support can be made using wood, composite plastic or aluminum. We use aluminum 1/2″ flat stock and cut it to length with a hacksaw, then drill the ends for screws. It is a simple job, and the aluminum stock is available at most hardware stores.

Raised Garden Beds Height Comparisons

Natural Cedar Raised Beds

Cedar raised beds come in six height options, from 5.5″, 11″, 16.5″, 22″, 27.5″ and 33″ (16.5″ height shown).

Composite Raised Beds

Composite beds come in four height options, from 5.5″, 11″, 16.5″ and 22″ (5.5″ height shown).

Farmstead Beds

Farmstead beds come in four height options, from 8″, 16″, 24″ and 32″ (24″ and 32″ heights shown).

Soil Depth Requirements for Popular Vegetables

Be Sure There Is Adequate Depth for the Roots of the Crops You Plant

In most gardens, the top 6″ of soil contains the most nutrients needed for plant growth. This is because most root growth in vegetable gardens occurs in this relatively shallow depth. Nutrients such as compost and fertilizers are added to the bed from above and lightly tilled in. Mulches are also 'top-dressed' throughout the growing season, and gradually decompose into the top layer of soil adding additional nutrients.

Taproots will travel deeper into the soil if nutrients and water are available, and this also brings more trace minerals to the plant. Larger vegetable plants will send down deeper roots. When plants are able to send their roots deeper, they are less likely to fall over in windy conditions or if the ground becomes too wet. Large-leafed, shallow-rooted plants such as broccoli, Brussels sprouts and cauliflower will still require staking to ensure they stay upright as they grow to maturity.

Knowing the average root depth for your garden vegetables will help you decide where to plant each crop and how deeply to prepare your soil.

When preparing a garden bed for planting, it is helpful to know the root depth of vegetable crops since this has a bearing on where you may decide to plant certain crops and how deeply the soil is prepared. For example, in our garden we may plant shallow rooted crops like lettuce in beds where the subsoil has more clay and does not drain well. The deeper clay does not affect the shallow roots, and they benefit from the added moisture. Plants with deeper roots, such as tomatoes, would not do well in this soil depth.

Some raised beds are set on cement patios or on gravel surfaces, which prevent roots from going deeper than the height of bed sides. In these cases, it is especially helpful to know the soil depth requirements of different vegetable crops. Gardeners can compensate by building the raised beds higher to allow for more root space. While raised beds are commonly 8″ – 12″ tall, some raised beds have sides which are 3′ or higher. These taller beds enable deeper rooted crops to be planted even if there is no soil beneath the bed, but drainage must be provided by blocking the bed up an inch or so, or drilling drain holes near the bottom of the bed sides.

Soil Depth Requirements for Common Garden Vegetables

Shallow Rooting 12" - 18"	Medium Rooting 18" - 24"	Deep Rooting 24" - 36"+
Arugula	Beans, dry	Artichokes
Broccoli	Beans, pole	Asparagus
Brussel sprouts	Beans, snap	Beans, lima
Cabbage	Beets	Okra
Cauliflower	Cantaloupe	Parsnips
Celery	Carrots	Pumpkins
Chinese cabbage	Chard	Rhubarb
Corn	Cucumber	Squash, winter
Endive	Eggplant	Sweet potatoes
Garlic	Kale	Tomatoes
Kohlrabi, Bok Choy	Peas	Watermelon
Lettuce	Peppers
Onions, Leeks, Chives	Rutabagas
Potatoes	Squash, summer
Radishes	Turnips
Spinach
Strawberries

Root Growth Pattern

For most vegetables, the bulk of the root mass is within the top six inches of soil. The soil should be light and well aerated to enable roots to access available nutrients. Deeper soil provides additional nutrients and trace minerals, which further facilitate plant growth. Plants will send some roots deeper if the soil conditions permit. When preparing soil for raised beds, 'double-digging' the soil will aerate this deeper soil and clear it of rocks and debris.

Height of Popular Vegetables at Maturity

Arrange Your Crops So Taller Plants Don't Block Shorter Plants from the Sun

When laying out a raised bed garden, the beds should be oriented to gain the maximum benefit from sun exposure. Beds should face south, and we suggest they be arranged horizontally facing south. This optimizes sun exposure from side to side across the bed, and keeps adjacent plants from shading each other as the sun moves east to west during the day.

Some gardeners prefer to layout their raised beds vertically to the sun (north to south), reasoning that this arrangement minimizes plants shading each other. This may make sense if you plan to grow a variety of crops in a single bed, and want to locate the taller plants at the rear (north) of the bed to prevent them from shading the shorter plants. However, we find it simpler to grow only one crop per raised bed because. Since the crop matures at the same time, the bed can be cleared after harvest and planted in a 'green manure' crop to restore nutrients in preparation for subsequent crops.

Note the height at maturity for each plant that you want to grow and organize your plantings with this in mind.

Regardless of how your garden beds are arranged, it is important to know how tall each of your planted crops will grow when mature. This is because you don't want some of your plants blocking others from the available sunlight. Shorter plants like lettuce and radishes should be planted on the south side of the beds, with mid-size plants behind, and the tallest plants to the rear (north) of the planted area. Plants such as pole beans and peas, which are planted against a trellis, will block a lot of light. Locate trellises with this in mind.

Wind is another factor to consider. Taller plants are more vulnerable to wind damage, so they may need to be staked, secured to a trellis, or located against a windbreak. Plants get much heavier once they begin to put out fruit, so trellises need to be well secured. The chart below gives the approximate heights at maturity for popular vegetables. This will help determine planting location and distance between plants when planting seed or setting out transplants.

Heights at Maturity for Popular Garden Vegetables

Vegetable	Size at Maturity	Vegetable	Size at Maturity
Artichoke	4' - 5'	Kohlrabi	9" - 12"
Arugula	8" - 10"	Leeks	12" - 24"
Asparagus	4' - 6'	Lettuce	6" - 12"
Beans, bush	24" - 30"	Okra	2' - 8'
Beans, lima (bush)	24" - 36"	Onions	8" - 24"
Beans, pole	8' - 12'	Parsnips	6" - 18"
Beets	4" - 12"	Peas	2' - 6'
Broccoli	18" - 24"	Peppers, hot	12" - 48"
Brussel sprouts	24" - 36"	Peppers, bell	24" - 36"
Cabbage	12" - 18"	Potatoes	12" - 30"
Carrots	6" - 15"	Pumpkin	12" - 24"
Cauliflower	12" - 30"	Radishes	2" - 6"
Celery	18" - 24"	Spinach	6" - 15"
Chard	12" - 30"	Rutabaga	12" - 18"
Chinese cabbage	12" - 24"	Spinach	6" - 15"
Corn	4' - 8'	Squash, summer	12" - 24"
Cucumber	1' - 5'	Squash, winter	12" - 24"
Eggplant	1' - 3'	Sweet potato	12" - 30"
Endive	6" - 9"	Tomatoes	2' - 8'
Garlic	12" - 24"	Turnips	6" - 12"
Kale	12" - 24"	Watermelon	12" - 36"

vegetables in raised bed In this garden the shortest plants, lettuce, are in the front facing north. A row of pole beans, tall plants at maturity, is planted behind the lettuce for late summer shade. The back row has carrots facing south, to fulfill their need for sunshine.

Container Gardening Tips: Growing Vegetables in Planters and Elevated Containers

Gardeners who lack the ground space for planting vegetables can grow in self-contained growing containers, such as planters and 'elevated' beds. South-facing balconies and patios can provide suitable growing conditions. Vertically grown plants like tomatoes, beans, peas, and cucumbers will greatly increase the yield of your space. Also, seed companies have developed many space-saving varieties for container gardening.

The primary concern when growing in planters or containers is drainage. Of course, suitable drainage must be provided so the roots don't rot in overly moist conditions. But moisture can drain through a planter quickly during hot dry conditions, and the planters must be re-watered regularly to prevent root stress and plant wilting. Drip-systems can be installed with timers on the hose, set to sprinkle during times you are away.

By understanding the rooting requirements of the plants you want to grow, you'll be more likely to provide ideal growing conditions that lead to bountiful harvests.

When choosing a planter or elevated container for growing vegetables, check to see that the bottom is constructed to allow for good drainage. Also check that the bottom is strong enough to hold the weight of the soil when it is wet. Slatted bottoms with inner permeable liners are a good choice when choosing a container for vegetable gardening.

By understanding the basics of rooting behavior and the rooting depth requirements of the plants you want to grow, you'll be more likely to provide ideal growing conditions that lead to bountiful harvests.

To buy a raised bed or planter suitable for growing vegetables, visit our Online Store.